My Amish neighbor showed me this dish. Guests have gone bonkers over it!

 

My Amish Neighbor Showed Me This Dish — Now My Guests Go Bonkers Every Time I Make It

By [Your Name]

---

There’s something magical about recipes that carry stories — the ones passed down not through cookbooks, but through hands and heart. One such recipe came to me in the most unexpected way: over a white picket fence, in the middle of a summer afternoon, from my kind-hearted Amish neighbor, Ruth.

I had always admired the quiet rhythm of Amish life from afar — the gardens, the baking, the smell of wood smoke in the air — but never thought I’d be let into one of its most treasured traditions: the kitchen.

One day, Ruth handed me a warm dish wrapped in a cotton towel and said softly, “This is something my mother used to make. Try it.” That night, I served it to my family — and then to guests at a dinner party the following weekend. I’ve made it dozens of times since, and every time, without fail, someone asks for the recipe. Some just say, “What is this?!” in amazement.

This dish is pure comfort. It’s humble, hearty, and nourishing — the kind of food that fills your home with warmth and your table with smiles.

---

A Glimpse into Amish Cooking

Before I share the recipe, I want to honor where it came from. Amish cooking is rooted in simplicity, tradition, and the idea of feeding not just the body, but the soul. Meals are made from scratch, using what’s in season and what’s been preserved with care.

Ruth told me that the recipe originated from her great-grandmother’s handwritten cookbook — a collection of stained, dog-eared pages passed down through generations. It wasn’t written with exact measurements, just pinches, handfuls, and instructions like “bake until it smells done.”

But even with such vagueness, there was one thing Ruth made clear: this dish was always made to be shared.

---

The Dish: Amish Chicken & Stuffing Casserole

The name doesn’t do it justice. Think of it as a deconstructed roast chicken dinner, layered in a casserole dish. Juicy shredded chicken, a creamy homemade sauce, and herbed bread stuffing come together in perfect harmony. No fancy techniques, no hard-to-find ingredients — just good, honest food.

This dish is rustic, cozy, and comforting — and yes, guests go bonkers over it.

---

Ingredients

Let’s start with what you’ll need. These ingredients are humble and pantry-friendly, just like the Amish tradition:

For the Chicken:

• 3–4 boneless, skinless chicken breasts (or thighs for extra flavor)

• Salt and pepper to taste

• 1 tsp onion powder

• 1 tsp garlic powder

• 2 cups chicken broth (for boiling or pressure cooking)

For the Sauce:

• 1 can cream of chicken soup (or use homemade)

• 1/2 cup sour cream

• 1/2 cup milk

• 1/4 cup butter, melted

• 1/2 tsp thyme

• 1/2 tsp sage (optional but traditional)

For the Stuffing:

• 1 package herbed stuffing mix (or 4 cups dried bread cubes + your own seasoning)

• 1/2 cup onion, finely chopped

• 1/2 cup celery, chopped

• 2 tbsp butter

• 1–1 1/2 cups chicken broth (to moisten)

---

Instructions

Step 1: Cook the Chicken

Place your chicken breasts in a pot with 2 cups of broth, onion powder, garlic powder, salt, and pepper. Simmer for 15–20 minutes or until fully cooked. Alternatively, use a pressure cooker for speed.

Remove from broth and shred the meat using two forks. Set aside.

Tip: Save the cooking broth — you’ll use it in the stuffing.

Step 2: Prepare the Stuffing

In a skillet, melt 2 tbsp butter and sauté the onion and celery until soft and fragrant (about 5 minutes). In a large bowl, combine sautéed vegetables with your stuffing mix or bread cubes. Add just enough warm broth to moisten — it should be soft but not soggy.

Homemade Version: Mix dried cubes of bread with poultry seasoning, parsley, thyme, and a pinch of sage.

Step 3: Make the Sauce

In a bowl, whisk together cream of chicken soup, sour cream, milk, melted butter, thyme, and sage. Add salt and pepper to taste.

Homemade Alternative: Make a quick roux-based sauce with butter, flour, chicken broth, and cream.

Step 4: Assemble the Casserole

In a greased 9x13" baking dish, layer the shredded chicken evenly on the bottom. Pour the creamy sauce over the chicken. Top with the stuffing mixture and spread evenly.

Step 5: Bake

Cover with foil and bake at 350°F (175°C) for 30 minutes. Uncover and bake for an additional 10–15 minutes, until the top is golden and crisp.

Let rest for 10 minutes before serving.

---

Why This Dish Works

This dish is all about balance:

• The savory chicken gives it heartiness.

• The creamy sauce adds richness without being heavy.

• The stuffing gives it texture and an herby punch.

It’s like a cozy Sunday dinner in one pan — no gravy or sides required (but they’re welcome!).

---

Serving Suggestions

Although the casserole is a full meal on its own, Ruth suggested these traditional pairings:

• Side: Buttered green beans or stewed tomatoes

• Bread: Homemade dinner rolls or biscuits

• Dessert: Shoofly pie or a scoop of homemade apple butter over vanilla ice cream

And always — always — a jug of sweet tea or fresh lemonade on the table.

---

Guests Can’t Get Enough

The first time I made this for guests, they assumed it was some complicated gourmet casserole. When I told them it came from an Amish neighbor and was made with soup and stuffing mix, their jaws dropped.

“I don’t even like stuffing, but I went back for seconds!”
“This is the kind of food you dream about during a long day.”
“Can you send me the recipe… tonight?”

Even my picky eater niece devoured it. That’s the magic of this dish — it turns skeptics into believers.

---

The Amish Way: Cooking from the Heart

This dish isn’t flashy. It won’t win any plating contests on Instagram. But it speaks volumes about what food is supposed to be: nourishing, generous, and shared.

Ruth once told me, “The best food isn’t perfect — it’s made with hands that care and hearts that give.” That’s stayed with me ever since.

In a world of food trends and viral recipes, dishes like this remind us that comfort food is timeless.

---

Make It Your Own: Variations & Tips

Want to adapt it? Here are some ideas:

🧀 Add Cheese:

Sprinkle shredded cheddar or mozzarella between the chicken and stuffing layers for a gooey surprise.

🥕 Add Veggies:

Mix in frozen peas, diced carrots, or green beans for a one-dish meal with added nutrition.

🐓 Use Leftover Chicken or Turkey:

Perfect for Thanksgiving leftovers — just sub in shredded turkey.

🐖 Try It With Ham:

A smoky twist that goes great with the creamy sauce.

---

Freezer Friendly & Crowd Approved

This casserole is ideal for batch cooking:

• Make-Ahead: Assemble up to 24 hours in advance and bake when ready.

• Freeze: Wrap tightly and freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight and bake as usual.

• Feed a Crowd: Double the recipe for potlucks, family gatherings, or church suppers.

I’ve brought this to baby showers, sick friends, and holiday dinners — and it’s always a hit.

---

Final Thoughts

It’s funny how a simple act of kindness — a neighbor sharing a dish — can turn into something you carry for a lifetime. This recipe is more than just food. It’s connection, comfort, and a little slice of a slower, simpler world.

I still make this dish at least once a month. Every time I do, I think of Ruth, her kindness, and the stories wrapped up in every bite.

So if you’re looking for a meal that brings people together, that makes them ask for seconds, and maybe even third helpings — try this Amish Chicken & Stuffing Casserole.

Because when food is made with love, people can taste it.

---

Printable Recipe: Amish Chicken & Stuffing Casserole

Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 40 minutes
Serves: 6–8

Ingredients:

(see above)

Instructions:

(see above)