Found This Thing in My Garden. Looks Creepy. Should I Get Rid of It?

There’s something deeply unsettling about stumbling across an unknown, strange-looking creature nestled between your hydrangeas or slinking beneath your tomato plants. Sometimes it’s a blob. Sometimes it has legs. Sometimes it just… pulses. You take a picture. You google. You ask around:

“Found this thing in my garden. Looks creepy. Should I get rid of it?”

You’re not alone.

Every gardener eventually comes face-to-face with a mysterious organism — insect, fungus, or something in-between — that causes alarm. And the question is always the same: is it dangerous, or is it actually helping?

In this guide, we’ll walk through the most common creepy-looking garden visitors, how to identify them, when to leave them alone, and when to take action — with a clever “garden recipe” to help you handle these situations like a pro.

Let’s dig in.

---

🌱 Chapter 1: What Did You Actually Find?

First things first — you’ve got to identify it.

Here are some common suspects that get labeled “creepy” in gardens:

🐛 1. Tomato Hornworms

• Looks like: Massive green caterpillars with white stripes and a horn on their rear.

• Creepy factor: High — they’re big, wriggly, and can strip a tomato plant overnight.

• Should you get rid of it?

  • Yes, if they’re actively eating your crops.

  • No, if you see white rice-like cocoons on their back — those are parasitic wasp larvae (great natural pest control).

🐌 2. Slugs and Snails

• Looks like: Slimy, slow, usually hiding under leaves or rocks.

• Creepy factor: Medium — they leave a shiny trail and munch holes in your lettuce.

• Should you get rid of it?

  • Yes, in excess. Use beer traps or copper tape.

  • No, if their population is small and your garden has natural predators like frogs.

🍄 3. Stinkhorn Mushrooms

• Looks like: Alien-looking, smelly fungi with a reddish tip or gooey top.

• Creepy factor: Off the charts.

• Should you get rid of it?

  • No, unless the smell bothers you. They're not dangerous and help break down decaying matter.

🐝 4. Solitary Ground Bees

• Looks like: Small bees digging tiny holes in your soil.

• Creepy factor: Low, but people confuse them with aggressive wasps.

• Should you get rid of it?

  • No. They're harmless pollinators and not aggressive.

🐛 5. Cutworms

• Looks like: Curled brown/gray caterpillars at the base of young plants.

• Creepy factor: Medium.

• Should you get rid of it?

  • Yes, they can kill seedlings overnight. Use collars around new plants.

🕷️ 6. Orb-Weaving Spiders

• Looks like: Big, scary spider with long legs and a large web.

• Creepy factor: High — especially if you walk into their web.

• Should you get rid of it?

  • Absolutely not. They eat flies, mosquitoes, beetles, and aphids.

🐞 7. Ladybug Larvae

• Looks like: Tiny, spiny black-and-orange alligators crawling on leaves.

• Creepy factor: High — they don’t look like adult ladybugs.

• Should you get rid of it?

  • No! Never! They eat hundreds of aphids in their larval stage.

---

🧪 Chapter 2: ID Test — Is It Friend, Foe, or Fungus?

Here’s a simple diagnostic recipe for figuring out whether your creepy garden visitor is a pest or a pal.

🌿 Garden Creepy Thing ID “Recipe”

Ingredients:

• 1 pair of gloves

• 1 magnifying glass or phone camera

• 1 internet connection

• 1 calm state of mind

Steps:

1. Observe Without Touching

   • Is it moving? Fast or slow?

   • What’s it near — plant, soil, wood?

   • What color and shape is it?

2. Take a Picture

   • Use a clear, well-lit shot. Zoom in.

3. Google Smartly

   • Use search terms like:
     "weird slimy thing under mulch"
"black spiky insect on tomato leaf"
"mushroom that smells bad"

4. Check These Sites:

   • BugGuide.net

   • iNaturalist

   • Reddit’s r/whatsthisbug

5. Determine One of Three Paths:

   • Friend (Pollinator, predator, decomposer)

   • Foe (Pest, disease vector, plant eater)

   • Fungus/Neutral (Often harmless decomposers)

---

🛡️ Chapter 3: The “Should I Get Rid of It?” Decision Tree

If you're still unsure whether to intervene, follow this logic:

1. Is it damaging plants?

   • YES ➡️ Consider organic removal methods.

   • NO ➡️ Go to next step.

2. Is it stinging, biting, or threatening humans/pets?

   • YES ➡️ Relocate or manage cautiously.

   • NO ➡️ Go to next step.

3. Is it rare or unusual?

   • YES ➡️ Might be worth leaving alone and documenting.

   • NO ➡️ Go to next step.

4. Does it appear in large numbers?

   • YES ➡️ Monitor. Large populations can become pests.

   • NO ➡️ Probably harmless.

---

🍽️ Chapter 4: A “Recipe” to Handle Creepy Garden Intruders

Now, here’s the creative recipe you've been waiting for — not for food, but for restoring balance when strange or scary things show up in your garden.

---

🧤 Garden Peace Recipe: “The Creepy Critter Cleanse”

YIELD: 1 peaceful, thriving garden
PREP TIME: 20–30 minutes
DIFFICULTY: Beginner-friendly
ALLERGY WARNING: May involve bugs.

---

🛒 Ingredients

• 1 pair of gardening gloves

• 1 spray bottle (filled with neem oil solution or mild soap water)

• 1 large bowl of soapy water

• Diatomaceous earth or crushed eggshells (optional)

• Copper tape or beer trap (for slugs)

• Patience and curiosity

• Your smartphone or ID guide

---

🥣 Instructions

1. Walk Through the Garden

   • Early morning or dusk is best — you’ll catch night-loving critters.

   • Carry your camera or phone to document anything odd.

2. Spot and Document

   • Don’t panic. Observe the behavior.

   • Take a photo. Try not to disturb unless necessary.

3. Capture What You Can

   • Use gloves or a stick.

   • Drop into soapy water if it’s confirmed harmful (e.g., cutworms, hornworms).

4. Apply Organic Deterrents

   • Neem oil spray: For aphids, whiteflies, and soft-bodied pests.

   • Diatomaceous earth: Lightly dusted around the base for crawling pests.

   • Beer trap: For slugs and snails.

5. Leave the Good Guys Alone

   • Spiders, ladybug larvae, praying mantis — these are garden heroes.

   • If in doubt, leave it.

6. Mulch Smartly

   • Fungi thrive in overwatered mulch. Turn and dry mulch regularly.

   • Remove soggy or moldy mulch and replace if needed.

7. Monitor and Revisit

   • Re-check in 48 hours.

   • Look for balance — are beneficials showing up?

---

💡 Bonus Tip: Encourage Natural Predators

The best defense against creepy pests? Predators that eat them.

Invite these into your garden:

• Frogs and toads: Provide shallow water and cover.

• Birds: Add birdbaths and feeders.

• Lizards: Avoid pesticides; they’ll help control bugs.

• Beneficial insects: Ladybugs, lacewings, and parasitic wasps can be purchased and released.

---

🧼 Chapter 5: Clean-Up and Prevention

After you’ve tackled the creepiness, keep things clean.

Regular Maintenance Recipe:

• Clean dead plant matter.

• Rotate crops each season.

• Avoid over-fertilizing (invites aphids).

• Use compost tea to boost plant immunity.

---

🍃 Chapter 6: Don’t Judge by Appearances

Gardens are ecosystems — not pristine labs. Creepy doesn’t always mean evil. In fact, many of the most helpful garden residents look downright terrifying.

That weird cocoon? Could be a moth.
That slime mold? It’s eating decomposing wood.
That "monster bug"? It’s hunting worse pests.

When you train your eye, you’ll stop asking “Should I get rid of it?” and start asking:
“What role does this creature play here?”

That’s the mark of a seasoned gardener.

---

🌿 Final Thoughts

The next time you’re out among your raised beds or vegetable patch and spot something strange crawling across your kale, take a deep breath. Get curious before you get rid of it. Most garden problems don’t require panic — just observation, information, and a few natural tools.

Because your garden isn’t just plants — it’s a tiny ecosystem, teeming with life. And like any community, some neighbors are weird, but some are wonderful.

So the answer to:

“Found this thing in my garden. Looks creepy. Should I get rid of it?”

Is almost always:

“Not before you know what it is.”